The Land Rover 5.0L Supercharged V8 is more powerful (510 hp vs. 400 hp), faster, and smoother, but it suffers from timing chain guide failures and higher maintenance costs. The 4.2L Supercharged V8 is more reliable, slightly more fuel-efficient, and has a rawer supercharged feel, but it lacks the low-end torque and refinement of the 5.0L. For reliability, go with the 4.2L; for performance, the 5.0L is the better choice.

The Land Rover Discovery 2 (1999–2004) is loved in the U.S. for its off-road capability, classic styling, comfortable interior, and strong enthusiast community. However, it's also infamous for reliability issues, head gasket failures, expensive repairs, poor fuel economy, and electrical problems. Enthusiasts appreciate its ruggedness and customization potential, while casual owners often find it a frustrating money pit. It’s a great adventure vehicle for those willing to maintain it, but not ideal as a hassle-free daily driver.